Mission No. 138

UDINE, ITALY   MISSION NO. 138   January 31, 1944
This is the official report of the mission, during which, 
Robert "Hooker" Kolstad's plane was shot down 

The Group wound up the busy month of January 1944 "with a bang" on the 31st and really plastered the airdrome installations at the Udine/Campoformido Base, which is just 3 1/2 miles southwest of Udine. It was one of the best jobs of precision bombing ever done by this unit and ended a month when twenty-four (24) missions were flown, which is a record for this Group, if not the Air Force. Twenty-nine (29) missions would have been flown, but the weather caused the cancellation of five of them. Incidentally, one of the twenty-four (24) missions flown was later declared "No Mission," but it has been counted here, for the formation was in the vicinity of the target and staved off a fighter attack, so credit's being taken for it. 

The installations there were extensive and included five large hangars, one medium hangar, barracks, guard room, control room, officer's mess, stores buildings, motor transport building, a school building and the officers' quarters, and all were in a confined V-shaped area that presented a beautiful target. 

There was some resistance that day, too, but it seems that, the greater the resistance, the better the bombing for, in many instances, when there wasn't any opposition, the bombing was below the usual standard. The first wave didn't get any flak, but the second wave did, and it was slight to moderate in intensity and fairly accurate. 

Some 25 to 30 fighters (Me-109s, FW-190s, and twin- engine planes) attacked the second wave, too, before, during, and after the bomb run. The fighters were aggressive and continued their attacks for about 18 minutes. All planes appeared to be using rocket shells, in addition to 50mm. and came in low, mostly between 5 and 7 o'clock to as close as 300 yards, in some instances. This resistance caused the loss of plane to flak, and fourteen (14) others were slightly damaged ( nine by flak and five by fighters), but no one was injured. 

The plane lost was from the 96th Squadron, and it was last sighted at 1305 hours at 45-08N - 13-44E, which is about thirteen 13) miles north-northwest of Pola, Italy. Apparently, it caught some damaging flak on the bombing run, but the plane dropped its bombs and stayed with the formation, until the turn was started, at which time it began to lag and go to the left. It nearly caught up to the formation several times, but finally lagged some distance and finally parachutes were seen coming from the plane. 

It seemed that the men had plenty of time to jump, for they came out of the plane at ten- second intervals. At least seven crew members were seen to bail out and, no doubt, they all did, for the for mation finally got so far away from the plane that no one could see exactly what happened to it. It was alone, at any rate, and not being molested by fighters. It was suspected, from the course the stricken aircraft assumed upon leaving the formation, that the pilot was trying to make it to Yugoslavia, before going down, for the crew members would have a better chance of not being taken prisoner in that country than they would have, if they landed on Italian soil. The missing men were

Robert R. Kolstad
     
1st Lt.  0-792717  Pilot; Eau Claire, Wisconsin 
Victor A. Brockman
      2nd Lt.  0-801504  Co-pilot; Nazareth, Texas 
John V. Harrop
    
2nd Lt.  0-811607  Navigator; Chicago, Illinois. 
James W. Shea
     2nd Lt.  0-731750  Bombardier; Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 
Archie M. Hartgrave 
     T/Sgt.  37120495  Upper Turret; Ainsworth, Nebraska
Hayden B. Speede 
     Sgt.  14151378  Lower Turret; Hattiesburg, Mississippi 
Joseph W. Gibson 
     S/Sgt. 12172678  Right Waist; Broadalbin, New York 
William K. Fleming Jr., 
     32536723  Left Waist; Tuckahoe, New York 
Joseph (NMI) Habif 
     12152216  Tail Gunner; Los Angeles, California 
Willard R. Parrish 
     T/Sgt.  34208980  Radio Gunner; Chattahoochee, Florida 

In return for the lost aircraft, the gunners shot down seven (7) of the aggressive fighters and credit was given to the following: 

DESTROYED 
Robert R. Thornton..... 1 FW-190
     S/Sgt. 6576284  Upper Turret Gunner, 49th Squadron
     Jacksonville, Florida 
John J. Kenlein..... 1 Me-109 
     Sgt. 32605551  Upper Turret Gunner, 49th Squadron 
     West Orange, New Jersey 
David A. Harris..... 1 FW-190
     Sgt.  31150756  Right Waist Gunner, 49th Squadron
     North Monmouth, Maine 
Cleo L. Corley..... 1 Me-109
     S/Sgt. 17046948  Tail Gunner, 96th Squadron 
     Independence, Missouri 
George W. Stasik..... 1 Me-109
     S/Sgt. 13107027  Right Waist Gunner, 96th Squadron 
     McKee's Rocks, Pennsylvania 
Arlin J. Stearns..... 1 me-109
     Sgt. 18169914  Tail Gunner, 96th Squadron 
     Paragould, Arkansas

PROBABLY DESTROYED 
Donald F. Center..... 1 FW-190
     S/Sgt. 18169171  Left Waist Gunner, 20th Squadron 
     Heber Springs, Arkansas. 

According to the bomb strike photographs taken by seven cameras, there were forty-five (45) aircraft on the ground at bombing time, forty-one(41) single- engine, and three (3) twin- engine, and one (1) multi- engine. Of these, nine (9) single- engine fighters were destroyed and four others were damaged by the two Groups that bombed. 

Other damage done by the 2nd Bomb Group included: a heavy concentration of hits that blanketed the northeast two-thirds of the installations with heavy destruction of buildings; a direct hit on the central hangar of the southeast line that probably destroyed it, as well as the small building adjacent to it; a damaging near miss on the extreme northeast hangar of the southeast line; direct hits and probable near misses on probable central and control administration building at the northeast end of the landing area between the two hangar lines; direct hits and damaging near misses on the north east half of the barracks buildings in the northeast hangar with partial demolition; direct hits on the two hangars and probable shops between them at the northeast end of the northeast hangar line, that partially demolished them; direct hits or very damaging near misses on seven of the nine buildings located between the northeast hangar line and the administration and quarters units, that severely damaged them; at least two of the five quarters buildings hit directly and severely damaged; direct hits and damaging near misses on the central and westerly of the three hangars under construction to the east of the quarters buildings, which partially destroyed them; several direct hits on the railroad adjacent to the airdrome on the north and the highway on the south, that cut the former in several places and cratered the latter; a small concentration on the south, that post-holed that portion along the south hangar line and about one-quarter of the width of the runway and many direct hits on the landing area between the two hangar lines that post-holed it well. 

The 2nd Bomb Group preceded the 99th Bomb Group over the target and was led by Captain Harold L. Chrismon, Commanding Officer of the 20th Squadron. 

The bombing took place at 1249 hours, from 22,000 feet and 117 tons of 1,000 general purpose demolition bombs were used. P-47 escort was furnished by the 325th Fighter Group. Two additional men, besides the combat crews, went on the mission. One was T/Sgt. Newey 0. Stephens of the Group Intelligence Section and the other was Sgt. Lowell A. Greer, Aerial Photographer from the 96th Squadron. 

This was the first time the latter had gone on a mission for that purpose, and it was the plan for him to procure photographs of the formation and oblique views of the bombing. His first attempts weren't too successful, however, he will be going on missions frequently and should be able to obtain some very good pictures for use in educational and public relations work.


UDINE, ITALY      MISSION NO. 138     January 31, 1944
Missing Air Crew Report: A/C No. 42-29608

Lts. Kolstad, Brockman, Harrop, Shea and Sgt. Hartgrave, Gibson, and Fleming evaded capture and returned to Allied control. T/Sgt. Parrish was captured and interned in prison camp. Sgts. Habif and Speede perished, when they parachuted into the sea and were not rescued. 

The following statements were taken from returning airmen, during interrogation, at the conclusion of the mission. 

S/Sgt. Stephen J. Hannon, Lower Turret Gunner on B-17 No. 42-31640, flying the Second Wave, First Squadron, Second Element, Lead Plane:
"I noticed that aircraft No. 608 was slowly drifting back from his place, on our right wing, as we returned from our target to the coast. As we crossed onto the Adriatic, he turned to the left and passed underneath us, about one thousand(1000) feet below us and six-hundred(600) yards behind. All four engines were on, and the plane was under good control. His course, east of ours, took him over the west part of the Istrian Peninsula. Shortly after he got over land, I saw a parachute open. Six 6) parachutes, altogether, opened at long intervals, all over land. After the sixth parachute opened, the plane seemed to be still flying, but we were passing beyond my range of vision, and I could see no more." 

S/Sgt. William E. McNichol, Right Waist Gunner on B-17 No. 42-31640:
"A/C No. 608 was flying on our right wing, in the 2-1-2-2 position. On the bomb run, I saw several bursts of flak close to him and, although I cannot be sure, I think that the flak must have damaged him. However, he dropped his bombs with us and stayed in formation until we started to turn off the bomb run. He, then, began to drop behind but, for a time, would come up; then drop behind again. After several times of this, he kept falling further behind. When we reached the Adriatic, he was a considerable distance behind the formation. Shortly after, I saw him make a turn to the left, and he passed out of my range of vision." 

The following is a statement of 2nd Lt. John V. Harrop, taken May 22, 1944, regarding missing crew members:
"When 1st Lt. Robert F. Kolstad, 0-792717, our first pilot, gave the signal to prepare to bail out, we were over the Adriatic Sea. The tail gunner, Sgt. Joseph Habif, 12152216 and the ball turret gunner, Sgt. Hayden B. Speede, 14151378, disconnected ear phones and bailed out immediately. This would put them three(3) to six(6) miles at sea. No more was ever heard of them again. The Partisans put up a search for all of us, and I am sure that, if they had reached shore safely, they would have known of it. Lt. Brockman stated that he believed Sgt. Speede to be dead." 

On June 6, 1944, Lt. Harrop gave the following testimony at the AAF Distribution Center No. 2 at Miami Beach, Florida:
"Plane was operating out of Amendola, Italy, on a mission to bomb Udine, Italy, 31 January 1944. The plane reached the target and released its bombs but was hit by flak during the bomb run. The tail was damaged and engines 1 and 2 were knocked out. The oil system was damaged and the pilot could not feather props of the damaged engines. Later, when the No. 2 engine caught on fire, the pilot ordered to get ready to bail out. Upon receiving these orders, the tail gunner, Sgt. Habif, and the ball turret gunner, Sgt. Speede, bailed out without further orders. The approximate position of the plane at this time was over the Adriatic Sea, ten(10) miles offshore, west of Trieste, Italy. 

The rest of the crew stayed with the plane until the pilot gave orders to ball out just offshore from the town of Rovigno, Italy. 

T/Sgt. William Fleming, the first man out, landed about 100 yards offshore and was picked up by natives and brought ashore. The rest of the crew bailed out and landed safely onshore. The plane crashed into the sea a short distance away. 

About four(4) days later, natives brought all members of the crew together, with the exception of S/Sgt. Ferrell and the two crew members who bailed out in the vicinity of Trieste. HEARSAY INFORMATION: Natives reported one crew member taken prisoner. It is the belief of the source (Lt. Harrop) that this was S/Sgt. Ferrell, since all others were accounted for. Source has no further information concerning Sgts. Habif and Speede."

NOTE: Lt. Harrop used the name of S/Sgt. Ferrell in his statement. However, the correct name was T/Sgt. Williard R. Parrish, radio operator. 

The following casualty statement was taken from 1st Lt. Victor A. Brockman on April 6, 1944 after evading capture:
"Our plane crashed at approximately 1305 hours, 31 January 1944, about 10 miles northeast of Pola, Italy in the Adriatic Sea. The wing section behind No. 1 engine was on fire and the propellers on No. 1 and No. 2 engines were running away. I bailed out at approximately 9,000 feet. None of the crew members were injured prior to bailing out. All the crew bailed out and all chutes were seen opening. The plane did not explode on striking the water but did sink immediately. I saw six other members of the crew on the ground. The plane was about ten miles from land and no life-preserving material could be seen. I received information from partisans that two members of the crew perished in the sea and that one member was made a prisoner of war. These members were not identified by same. I believe that Lt. Harrop, Sgt. Hartgrave, Sgt. Fleming, and Sgt. Gibson are safe with the partisans or have already joined their units in Italy. They were safe when I left them and plans were being made for their evacuation. I believe that Sgt. Speede and Sgt. Habif perished in the sea because of reports from partisan sources and believe that Sgt. Parrish was made a prisoner of war because of partisan reports." 

The following statement was taken from T/Sgt. William H. Fleming after evading:
"We left the formation about 50 miles north of Pola, Italy. Everyone bailed out through their own personal escape hatches, except the bombardier who came back to the waist position to make sure that everyone was clear. Just before we hit the silk, everyone was in good condition." 

T/Sgt. Joseph W. Gibson, Right Waist Gunner:
"I bailed out, as well as some others, but don't know if anyone was in the plane when it struck the water. We all landed two to five (or more) miles apart. The pilot said later that he was the last one out. I met the left waist gunner, engineer, pilot, co-pilot, navigator, and bombardier about two weeks after I hit the ground."